The Season One contest’s goal was to have our listeners take lackluster Commanders and reinvent them to provide a new, superior, and fun alternative to the existing version of that creature. The rules of the contest were loose, and winning criteria was extremely subjective. We just wanted to see cards that were fun and creative. Deciding a winner was conducted through the first-ever Circle of Judgment, which was formed from not only a few podcasters, but also mail-in opinions from some CommanderCast affiliates.

The winner of he Generals Remixed contest received a free altered card from Sandreline.

To check out the Circle of Judgment itself, click here.

To see a gallery of all the entries, click here.

Ultimately, the following card design prevailed: