This entry is part 95 of 542 in the series CommanderCast

Posted by ANDY aka GHoooSTS

Show notes and pertinent links below. Enjoy.


00:00 to 04:05: Introduction: Here’s a list of people on the show


04:15 to 32:31: WotC’s Magic Report Card for TWENTY-DOZ: Employees at WotC have been shitting their pants over the last two or three weeks in anticipation of our harsh-but-fair judgment of their overall performance throughout 2012. In this segment, three stern-faced judges–men cut of the hardest stuff, with no tolerance for even slight missteps–will take a look at everything released this year from the perspective of Commander players.

What was awesome? What was bullshit? There will be decrees made, judgements passed, and maybe even some dick jokes. Check it out!

Dark Ascension

  • Probably the worst product of the year
  • A low power level and lots fo boring cards combined to make an uninspiring set
  • A fair number of good reprints and less-noticable but still important utiity cards
  • Where’s the transforming legend at?

Avacyn Restored

  • A return to high power levels and absurd effects at the heavy end of the mana scale
  • Miracle is a hit-and-miss mechanic in EDH and the ‘lone wolf’ thing fell flat as it could have
  • Overall, this was a well-liked product with a few missteps, but almost everyone got something from it


  • Big mana spells are getting out of control
  • Included a ton of great reprints of older, classy, or hard-to find cards like Akroma’s Memorial
  • The new cycle of monocoloured legends were nice, clean, and overall well-executed
  • Core set fatigue may be setting in for some players

Return to Ravnica

  • Overall, hot fire without question, living up to the hype
  • Tons of great EDH cards across all the colours and mana costs
  • The return of multicolour to centre stage will always be apreciated by Commander players

Commander’s Arsenal

  • Presentation was lacking for a premium product
  • It seems Wizards is probing the waters for new and different demographics of Commander players with mixed results
  • ‘Production quality’ tokens, oversized cards and other weird extras feel out of place

Planechase 2012

  • Maybe the best product of the year: great new Legends, the new planes were awesome, and fun new cards
  • Included a Demon Ninja

From the Vault: Realms

  • A return to form from From the Vault: Legends, but isn’t going to turn people who aren’t already into FTV products
  • Why are we still getting troll cards in here like Desert?

Venser vs Koth Duel Deck

  • Really middle-of-the-road, not much standing out
  • Dave takes a messy dump on this product: don’t buy this looking to ‘open for value’

Izzet vs Golgari Duel Deck

  • Awesome duel decks with good cards
  • No fear of unconventional mechanics that aren’t necessarily new-player friendly

Overall Evaluation

David: B+ to A-

Graybeard: A-

Andy: B+


1:00:00 to 1:17:30: Unfomfortable Situations: No, I’m not talking about the greased-up neckbeard across the room awkwardly making tongue gestrues at you. When that happens, you don’t need a nerdy podcast, you need the 5-0 (but do remember snitches get stitches). What we’re discussing is things that happen in-game that should be triggering your alarm bells; stuff that you can’t quite predict the outcome on, but does give you a bad feeling. An Eldrazi about to Annhilate somebody or something, and no clear target? How about your man with a Rings of Brighthearth in play and the game isn’t over yet? Listen in and learn to make your hosts deeply unsettled.


1:17:46 to 1:39:48: DERP TECH: Every now and then, you just gotta derp it up. After all, a man whose two eyes are always perfectly straight and aligned ain’t a man to trust. Graybeard suggested we enshrine some of our favourite durdly-derpin’ cards in a segment, and I think we put the team on our collective backs doe.


2:01:58 to END: Dat Outtro: Thanks for listening!

Contact Information:

Andy: commandercast(at)gmail(dot)com // (at)commandercast
Dave: derfington(at)gmail(dot)com // (at)derfington
Graybeard: angrygraybeard(at)gmail(dot)com // (at)irememberbanding

Series Navigation<< CommanderCast S8E2 [94]- Honoured AlumniCommanderCast S8E4 [96] – Who ruined the format now? >>

135 Responses to “CommanderCast S8E3 [95] – Iron Mics”

  1. Jiisuri said

    Randomly, another card with a ! in it’s name is “To Arms!” from Guildpact. Pondering the potential fun to be had with that one.

  2. You are crazy…Dark Ascension has a bunch of cards I play. JAR OF EYEBALLS or Requiem Angel being my favorites.

  3. my friends call renegade doppelganger “blue haste”. It fits what it does.

  4. DERP PICKS! You guys basically outlined my Riku CHAOS deck in that segment.

  5. Wil Blanks said

    As far as Renegade Doppleganger is concerned, it was printed in Rise, so I figure it was intended to work with Level Uppers. But they kind of stink, so why not try something like Aethermage’s Touch instead?

  6. More said

    Thank you

    What computer should I buy to run an Adobe CS4 Suite at full speed?

  7. Trackback said


    I just downloaded Mozilla firefox, how do i make it so my opening page is bebo? I know its possible i just can’t remember how. I mean so that when you open firefox its not google its bebo, if yous get what i mean?.

  8. Trackback said


    can any post on a personal blog (with disclaimer that it is his personal view) be used by any brand for filing a case against an individual for ‘brand tarnishing’ etc?.

  9. Trackback said

    I have some question

    Without asking them to delete it, is there a way i can delete my own blog comments on someone else’s blog? Please help(:.

  10. Trackback said


    Where can I find legitimate blogs that are focused on or at least delve seriously into penis enlargement?

  11. Trackback said

    I like your blog

    I want to start a blog to write about everything that happens at school and with friends… anonymously… any sugestions?.

  12. Trackback said

    wow thats great

    How do I start a website that costs me nothing at all?

  13. Trackback said

    Like it

    I have a blog made with Blogger and it has Blogger logos at the top.. I’ve seen Blogger blogs without them, and it makes them a lot cooler..

  14. Trackback said

    I like your blog

    There so many different computer tech stuff like Computer Programming, Computer Support Specialists, Computer Systems Analysts. I just want to know what it would be to go work on computers like store or business computers mess up or like tearing comput…

  15. song writing is the act of putting

    up lyrics and melodies to a song. mostly, writers compose songs according to their experiences and views in life. for example, country sweetheart taylor swift loves to write songs of her former lovers and crushes. swift’s songs “forever and always,”…

  16. tips for success as a b2b blogger.sincerity

    – about connecting to and helping your customersyou know what your customer’s needs, interests, and pain points are. and you’re genuinely concerned with helping them succeed. you’re not afraid of answering the hard questions and you welcome dialogue…

  17. offers you get to write for others.

    pay-per-click- some bloggers can do very well with pay-per-click but others may not do as well. there are several things that will determine how much money you can make with this method but it’s something that you can try to see

  18. wordpress blog theme customization because it is

    highly easy to install and upgrade. most of times, it works as a complete online store management tool. by using the particular web application, a person can customize and integrate the wordpress powered blog theme as per his business i…

  19. their lives will fine tune their skills.

    do you think you can’t be in the same room with your husband? is that the reason why you filed a divorce? so what now? what do you do after that divorce? you definitely deserve a good pat at the back.

  20. appropriate for achievement of the tasks of

    website promotion.article writing is important multiple methods are used by web developers to develop the website but there are certain methods that yield better results than others. writing articles and submission to web directories and link building…

  21. fierce. publishers have three-foot piles of manuscript

    submissions, sometimes monthly — i’ve seen the piles. nothing will get your manuscript trashed faster than sloppiness, spelling errors, and not following their rules. they get so many manuscripts, they can afford to be picky. but don’t worry, most o…

  22. i’ve seen many bloggers get great results

    just because their title was above and beyond what most people would write. make sure that it is compelling to read and captures the attention of your target audience right away. use words that target the emotions and cause people to

  23. kept trying the cranberry, zinc and immune

    supporting vitamins. they would work to some extent, but i would end up getting antibiotics from the doctor if i had not caught the infection in time.this last time, i could feel it coming. and, most women who have bladder infections

  24. often have a team of dedicated writers

    who specialize in different content fields. they have varying levels of expertise that helps produce exceptional quality content for all your needs. this is far much beneficial than hiring a single in-house writer.another benefit of outsourcing content…

  25. is to make it real to the

    five senses of your reader. your reader must see and hear, taste, smell, or touch the elements of your topic. your reader must know – and like – the characters in your story or the topics of your essay. sensory details,

  26. there is a huge difference between writing

    and good writing.when i started to write i just sat at the computer and typed whatever came out. i would focus entirely on the things i wanted to say but not on the words i was using to say them. sadly,

  27. hasn’t happened before or that it won’t

    happen again. and let’s not just pick on china, as many other countries are doing the same thing. did you know that iran actually has a minister of internet censorship? yes, it is true, it is actually a branch of government;

  28. I like your blog

    Where is a good place start a website for business at a very low price?

  29. you are writing about topics that your

    potential clients will be interested in as well as topics relevant to your company. a perfect example of this is best western’s travel blog – you must be trippin’. in this blog you can find a wealth of information about travel

  30. as you can see there are

    many advantages to owning your blog and by putting it on the best blogging platform around, wordpress.orgif you are serious about your online business then investing in a blogging platform like this will pay off in the long run. our world

  31. experian said

    you or your company, and that can

    make or break your credibility, then you can’t afford to have anything less than top quality. poorly written website content, articles, newsletters, white papers, media briefs, etc. will reflect badly on you and your business.2. evaluate the “fit” o…

  32. trawnik said

    whether the article writing services you are

    opting for offers a flexible and palatable package. till date the best way of website optimization is effective article submission to different directories. it will not only give high website ranking to the site in the result pages of the search

  33. view more said

    including a definite end date on your

    blog giveaway hardly inspires confidence in potential entrants. it is not enough to state a day of the week that it ends. i have seen many blog giveaways that state something like “giveaway ends next monday.” it is never a good

  34. learn more said

    art of creating a sentence. to successfully

    complete english composition, you will need to be able to write complete, coherent, and meaningful sentences. consequently, in this course, you may be subject to review sentence types, including the simple sentence, compound sentence, complex sentence,…

  35. Home said

    looking templates but unlike blogger, wordpress does

    not allow you to customize the available templates to the same degree.these two blogging platforms qualify to be the biggest blog site. blogger is the winner when it comes to setting up a free blog. you can get started with your

  36. your site. for instance, if you have

    a high bounce rate, that means the users are coming to your site and leaving without clicking on any additional pages. you can try to lower this bounce rate by adding recent posts on your sidebar, adding category headers or anything

  37. subscription platforms etc. instead of having to

    oversee the writer’s entire body of writing. article marketing strategies are used by many online business owners to generate traffic to their websites. the objective of the article is to generate traffic to a website so that sales can be made.

  38. are optimizing excessively when your keywords in

    posts and titles suddenly stop making sense.on the other hand, you also need to look at how many keywords you are stuffing into your information. too much seo’ing means that you are purely writing for the robots, and that is very

  39. you have crappy content no one will

    want to visit your blog and if they do they will leave because you have nothing good to offer. sometimes it can be hard to write good content. one of the best ways to find good ideas to write about is

  40. writers and having to mentor them constantly

    can be a real pain when it comes to running a design magazine, website or blog, which has so many business aspects to monitor.hiring an experienced, knowledgeable and motivated writer can help you concentrate on business promotion, advertising revenue…

  41. articulo said

    articles for you about your business. these

    articles will contain a specific word that relates to what you sell or the service you have. once someone searches for the specific word you placed your website will be the one that comes up. this is called search engine

  42. Soccer IQ said

    then why do so many blogs look

    like crap? aye, aye, aye…here are some tips in order to create a successful blog…1.) avoid a crappy looking headeri mean, really? have you seen some of the blog headers out there? they look like they were put together in 5

  43. or make much money.second, think specifically about

    your audience. why are they visiting your blog and what do they hope to get out of it? are they coming to learn about a specific skill set (for example, painting with oil based paint) or are they coming to get

  44. than one of your articles at a

    time, so there’s not much opportunity for comparison. with that said though, if your really want to have a writer who “sounds like you”, there are some things that you can do. here are some article marketing tips to help you

  45. working within an seo framework. so if

    you have knowledge of seo, your client will have more confidence in your ability to produce the type of content that is demanded.learn these seo writing tipssearch engine optimization is a vast subject, and one that is not limited to writing,

  46. article can be a momentous task for

    many and the routine of submitting new content every day can put many off. with the adventure of submitting articles come the guidelines of each site you submit to.even the most successful writer needs reminding occasionally of the standards expected b…

  47. prevalent in idaho, and it makes good

    posts if you cut trees that have much heartwood or split the white wood off. when you put a post in the ground the white wood quickly rots off, but the black heartwood may last 50 years in the is

  48. and then give yourself the luxury of

    edits. the most common question i get asked about blogging would be “how do you start a blog?”for this particular post, i’m going to show you how to start a successful blog (a professional one) in easy steps. if you know

  49. make sure you are satisfied with the

    writing before you pay the rest of the bill.the next time you are looking for a good writing service, you need to use these three tips when choosing seo content writers. there are companies that charge more, but you are getting

  50. leaning heavily on the internet, bloggers can

    have the great opportunity to earn money. there’s even no need to go to a conventional workplace and clock in for work. you can do your job from the comfort of your own home and at any time you choose. as

  51. article let’s talk about 5 ways to

    make money writing on the net. all of these can be carried out on a part-time basis, and even turned into a full-time business if that is your goal.1. blog writer. millions of blogs need to have content added to them

  52. fashion industry, offer tips on how your

    readers can pick the best set of clothes for specific events, or offer how-to guide on how they can save money from buying clothes online. these types of topics will allow you to attract qualified prospects. not only that, they’ll also

  53. to the topics that you would like

    to cover on your posts. you would want to know the information that’s already out there so you can figure out how you can make your posts unique or way better. also, interview other experts if you think that there’s a

  54. to increase protein intake and have a

    lot of fruits and minerals. it not only helps the mother to shed extra weight but also gives the right kind of nutrition to the baby till such time he or she can be fed other food apart from mother’s milk.the

  55. are looking for an opportunity to write

    professional posts about any topic imaginable. while many of these writers advertise themselves on popular websites, many business owners have come to rely on the services provided by article marketing companies. this way, the business owner simply pro…

  56. work well are:1. motivational and inspirational ideas

    – any niches chosen for the blog must be able to present contents that will inspire the customer and he will get motivated and take action. your approach must be real and genuine, which will help the readers to get all

  57. people choose your blog post over a

    different blog site. if you really want to get the attention of your target audience, use words that target their emotions. push their buttons a little.4. interview an expert in your niche. one blog post writing tip that you could use

  58. the assignment done, and seldom proofread or

    edit-unless that process is covered in class-a process that definitely will not happen in college. in college, students are often given multiple papers to write per semester in more than one class. college students must write in an academic style that

  59. solving a few issues you may be

    having yourself.always remember though to be helpful and courteous and always, always remember to thank your readers and fellow bloggers!isabella fiorentino as a blogger it would be very imperative to have a blog name that suits the picture you would w…

  60. lies on how you put your thoughts

    in writing. when you do so, you need your reader to want to get valuable content. you want to gain their interest and want them to read more of you. to start with your english should be reasonably good. if you

  61. apt [link] reported by 15 year old

    news.”@lanta, gawant to really target your traffic? the at symbol followed by the twitterer’s user name (e.g. @justsayburritno) ensures that the targeted user, regardless of who’s following whom, will be notified of your tweet on their homepage. doi…

  62. different article directories with their articles being

    around 200-250 words long, but an article this short typically has only 1 purpose:to sell you on something.even if you see the “gurus” doing it, don’t do it. people know the difference between good content and poor content. if you want

  63. this visitor is upset and confused because

    of all the advertising. so, they decide to close the tap on their internet browser. this happens often to other bloggers. don’t let it happen to you. i suggest that you write very clean blog posts and focus on the topic

  64. More Info said

    bloggers as a rule do write quite

    a bit! for the most part when publishing a blog post your primary goal is to keep people interested enough to return and provided your content quality is good enough, they will! another important aspect of your blog posting however is

  65. quite a few such diets and choosing

    the best post pregnancy diet is very critical and imperative to returning back to the same level as she was before pregnancy. many women think it is not possible but the fact of the matter is that it is very much

  66. there are many other cool ways to

    get awesome backlinks and i am going to share some. the first and greatest is ezinearticles; this is the best and fastest way to get a respected backlink to your blog. just write an article and add a link back to

  67. should be able to crawl and understand

    your content. blog writing is getting a little tricky! but if that’s what your audience (search engine and readers included) are expecting, wouldn’t you rather work on it and deliver? you are right. and worry not, here are a few tips

  68. better (at the onset at least). here

    are a few tips to get you started.learn how to researchone of the mistakes new article writers consistently make is that they simply neglect to learn how to research. to write a good article, your first step should be research. if

  69. pre-set templates provided by the site. this

    being said, you are in full control of the aesthetics and technical specs of your blog site. then again, this kind of ‘online freedom’ is not for free. its free version is known as the, which in turn does not

  70. an e-mail list. you can do this

    by offering a free report or something along those lines. just get out there and go for it! blogging is one of the best ways to grow your business and drive a lot of traffic. people spend hours on blogs reading

  71. The Absent Game

    Among me and my husband we have owned extra MP3 players over the years than I can count, such as Sansas, iRivers, iPods (classic & touch), the Ibiza Rhapsody, etc. But, the last few many years I’ve settled down to one line of gamers.

  72. van zandt songs are found here, with

    highlights being “poncho and lefty,” “loretta,” and “mr. mudd and mr. gold.” for those who (like me) purchased the deluxe edition, there is a companion album called “townes basic” which, for me, is the reason this album makes the top 5.

  73. give it a try, if you do

    not like it deactivate it and delete. not a problem13. related posts thumbnails – this cool plugin allows related posts to be seen on the side bar and at the bottom of your posts with the featured image, giving your reader

  74. Websites we think you should visit…

    Sites of interest we have a link to…

  75. diet dr said

    Sites we Like…

    Here are some absolutely unrelated websites to ours, nonetheless, i think you should take a second and visit the website…

  76. in the title! the title should be

    relevant to the blog that follows of course. blog writing definitely does not mean writing lengthy pieces of information. well, it does not mean writing too less too. if you are using graphics, maintain a good graphics to text ratio. seo

  77. difficult, to try to keep track of

    several long and tightly spaced paragraphs is frustrating enough to send your readers in search of another way to find out what they want to know. bad writing is often bad because the writer tries too hard to make it good.

  78. to loads of blogs then doing nothing

    again, you will get some visitors from your posts but then your name and post will disappear into the archives.however if there were a few sites that you constantly wrote for, your name will become recognizable, and if readers of your

  79. do is spend at least an hour

    per day writing. as you might know, ninety percent of success is showing up. if you show up everyday you will have lots of great content on the forum.3. stay positive. forums are just like any other interaction with people. there

  80. to focus on creating a schedule that

    works for you. what time of the day would you rather be writing? how many articles are you able to write in an hour without sacrificing quality content? these are questions you must answer if you ever hope to improve your

  81. Trackback said

    wow thats great

    How to make a select category on wordpress use a different domain?

  82. had no first-hand experience with blogging, back

    then i was active blog reader and commenter and already knew a couple of the big names in the blogosphere. i never imagined i would be able to build a community of thousands of readers, who i interact with every day.back

  83. The Slave of the Husband

    In search of ahead to researching added from you afterward!…

  84. Auto Pawn 575 Irwin

    Auto Equity Loan Cons

  85. Read was interesting, stay in touch….

    Well written!

  86. Info said


    […]that is the end of this post. Here you will uncover some websites that we consider you’ll value, just click the links over[…]

  87. Trackback said

    Good info

    I want to start my own blog: are there such thing as blogs that are totally “open”, and anybody can view it? I keep coming to the kind where you have to add other “friends” to use the site.. Links appreciated. Thanks!.

  88. Seo said


    […]Every when inside a while we opt for blogs that we read. Listed beneath would be the most current web sites that we choose […]

  89. News said


    […]The information and facts talked about within the write-up are a few of the top obtainable […]

  90. Tech said


    […]that would be the end of this article. Here you’ll find some websites that we think you’ll appreciate, just click the links over[…]

  91. Health said

    Marsten Blog’s

    […]Sites of interest we have a link to[…]

  92. Finance said

    Revupmi site

    […]Here are a few of the web sites we suggest for our visitors[…]

  93. Liberty said

    Lost in Liberty Blog

    […]please go to the websites we adhere to, such as this 1, as it represents our picks from the web[…]

  94. The Birch of the Shadow

    I believe there may perhaps become a couple of duplicates, but an exceedingly useful listing! I have tweeted this. Many thanks for sharing!

  95. Wonderful story …

    Here are a handful of unrelated data, nonetheless definitely worth taking a your time to visit this website

  96. bankruptcy edmo

    bankruptcy definitions

  97. bankruptcy eastern district california

    bankruptcy attorney fees

  98. bankruptcy home settlement in texas

    bankruptcy court nj

  99. bankruptcy explanation letter employment

    bankruptcy and student loans

  100. Nursing Career

    […]very handful of web sites that occur to be in depth beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly very well worth checking out[…]

  101. Business said


    […]check below, are some entirely unrelated internet websites to ours, even so, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  102. mark adderley

    […]Every after inside a while we opt for blogs that we read. Listed below would be the most current web pages that we decide on […]

  103. ultimate demon review

    […]usually posts some very intriguing stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[…]

  104. best penis extender that really work

    […]Here is a good Blog You may Find Interesting that we Encourage You[…]

  105. Wonderful story …

    Here are a number of unrelated information, nonetheless actually worth taking a your time to visit this website

  106. Wonderful story …

    Here are a couple of unrelated data, nonetheless truly really worth taking a your time to visit this website

  107. Coupons said

    Websites we think you should visit…

    Sites of interest we have a link to…

  108. Freedom said

    Websites we think you should visit…

    Sites of interest we have a link to…

  109. Sites we Like…

    Here are some completely unrelated internet websites to ours, even so, you can take a second and visit the website…

  110. Just check this …

    Just take a second to take a look at the internet sites we’ve linked to …

  111. Sites we Like…

    Here are some absolutely unrelated internet websites to ours, however, just take a second and visit the website…

  112. cash loan said

    New Payday Loans

    Fast Payday Loans No Credit Check

  113. Websites we think you should visit…

    Sites of interest we’ve a link to…

  114. What Are Faxless Payday Loans And How Do They Work

    Payday Loan Windsor

  115. You must see this website …

    We came across a cool site that you simply might enjoy visiting …

  116. Just check this …

    Just take a second to visit the internet sites we have linked to …

  117. Read was interesting, stay in touch….

    Perfectly written!

  118. Like said

    Just check this …

    Just take a second to pay a visit to the internet sites we’ve linked to …

  119. More info said

    You should check this out…

    Here are some completely unrelated websites to ours, having said that, just take a second to visit …

  120. lotofacil said

    You must see this website …

    We came across a cool web-site which you may enjoy visiting …

  121. Websites we think you should visit…

    Sites of interest we have a link to…

  122. Great websites from the internet…

    Very good written! Let me suggest you this interesting websites …

  123. Read was interesting, stay in touch….

    Well written!

  124. sameer said

    This can be amazingly logical factor as greater inside article. Enjoy speaking of about.

  125. Lesli said

    After study a number of of the blog posts on your web site now, and I really like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website record and will likely be checking back soon. Pls check out my web page as nicely and let me know what you think.

  126. I use iphoto among the wife’s imac and the mac book. It’s my job to down load typically the pictures in the apple macbook, work with these individuals, then export these having a UNIVERSAL SERIAL BUS for you to take back storage space in the laptop. Do they offer way to do this kind of along with “dropbox” while using the person?
    nike tn requin

  127. please, re-upload this ??? thanks !! xoxo

  128. salesforce said

    You should check this out…

    Here are some absolutely unrelated websites to ours, however, just take a moment to visit …

  129. The Zune concentrates on being a Portable Media Player. Not a web browser. Not a game machine. Maybe in the future it’ll do even better in those areas, but for now it’s a fantastic way to organize and listen to your music and videos, and is without peer in that regard. The iPod’s strengths are its web browsing and apps. If those sound more compelling, perhaps it is your best choice.

  130. Greetings! Quick question that’s totally off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My weblog looks weird when viewing from my iphone 4. I’m trying to find a template or plugin that might be able to resolve this issue. If you have any suggestions, please share. With thanks!

  131. I’ve recently started a website, the information you provide on this website has helped me tremendously. Thanks for all of your time & work.

  132. I am not sure where you’re getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more. Thanks for magnificent info I was looking for this information for my mission.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *